Move From MemberPress to Smart Creator Press Without Losing Members

How do you move from MemberPress to Smart Creator Press?

Smart Creator Press has a built-in MemberPress migration tool that moves each course’s title, description and featured image, plus its modules, lessons and attached files. Memberships, members and billing take a few more steps. You create memberships, import members from a CSV and map active Stripe and PayPal subscriptions so renewals keep billing without anyone typing in a card again.

What does the migration cover?

  • Moves with the tool: Course details, modules, lessons with all content, and attached PDFs, documents and download links.
  • You rebuild: Memberships, products, prices and custom styling are not moved.
  • Members: Import them from a CSV under Smart Creator, Members, Import.
  • Subscriptions: Map active Stripe plans and PayPal products to Smart Creator Press memberships.
  • Records: Past orders and transaction history are not listed in the doc, so keep your MemberPress exports.

📚

Your MemberPress courses

⟶

🔁

Migration tool + member import

⟶

🎉

Live in Smart Creator Press

courses, lessons and files move; memberships you rebuild

The MemberPress migration tool moves your courses for you. Memberships, members and billing take a few more steps, and active Stripe and PayPal subscriptions can keep billing without anyone typing in a card again.

By Veena Prashanth, creator of the award-winning SMART Suite · Last updated October 2, 2026 · Prices checked that day on MemberPress pricing, smartcreatorpress.com and the SCP MemberPress migration doc.

$699

MemberPress Growth a year, after a $349.50 first year

Source: memberpress.com/pricing, Oct 2, 2026

4.9%

fee per payment on MemberPress Launch

Source: memberpress.com/pricing, Oct 2, 2026

$229

Smart Creator Press 1-Site Elite a year, listed price

Source: smartcreatorpress.com, Oct 2, 2026

The short answer

It doesn’t move memberships, products, prices or custom styling. You create memberships in SCP, import members from a CSV under Smart Creator → Members → Import, then map your active Stripe plans and PayPal products so renewals keep billing where they already are.

Pick Smart Creator Press if your MemberPress renewal ($399 to $999 a year after the first year, as of October 2, 2026) is more than you want to keep paying, and you want bumps, upsells, affiliates and email in one plugin at a listed $229 a year. Stay on MemberPress if you’re mid-launch, or you want members and memberships moved by a tool too.

The renewal email shows a number about twice what you paid last year. MemberPress does say it on its pricing page: “Special introductory pricing, all annual renewals are at full price.” So you start wondering whether moving is worth it, and what breaks if you try.

I’ve built WordPress membership and checkout software since 2010, and I run my own business on the SMART Suite. This page takes my MemberPress migration doc and turns it into the full plan, including the parts the tool leaves to you. Coming from somewhere else? See every migration guide.


What the migration tool moves

Here’s the honest split. The tool handles your course content. Everything about who paid for what is on you, with a guide for each piece.

WhatMoves with the toolWhat you do
Course title, description, featured image✓ YesNothing
Modules and lessons, with all lesson content✓ YesSpot-check a few lessons
Attached resources (documents, PDFs, download links)✓ YesClick a few downloads
Memberships and productsNoCreate them in SCP
PricesNoSet them again in SCP
Custom stylingNoTweak formatting if your courses used custom CSS
MembersNoCSV import at Smart Creator → Members → Import
Active Stripe and PayPal subscriptionsNoMap them to SCP memberships

Source: MemberPress to SCP Migration on scpdocs.smartcreatorpress.com, checked October 2, 2026. Past orders and transaction history aren’t listed in the doc, so keep your MemberPress exports.

Bottom line

If your MemberPress site is mostly courses, the tool does the heavy part. If it’s mostly memberships with little course content, plan for the manual steps below.


What MemberPress costs to keep

Before you spend a weekend on a move, it’s worth knowing what staying costs. These are the MemberPress plans as listed on October 2, 2026.

PlanFirst yearAfter year oneFee per payment
Launch$199.50$3994.9%
Growth$349.50$699None
Scale$499.50$999None

Source: memberpress.com/pricing, checked October 2, 2026.

Smart Creator PressYearlyMonthly
1-Site Elite$229$20
3-Site Elite$269$25
5-Site Elite$299$30

Listed prices on smartcreatorpress.com, checked October 2, 2026. The site lists the same core features on every Elite tier; only the number of sites changes.

A year after your first one

MemberPress Scale$999
MemberPress Growth$699
MemberPress Launch, before fees$399
Smart Creator Press 1-Site Elite, listed$229

Bar width = price ÷ $999. MemberPress prices from memberpress.com/pricing; SCP is its listed price.

What the 4.9% Launch fee adds in a year

$1,000 a month in sales$588
$3,000 a month in sales$1,764
$5,000 a month in sales$2,940

Monthly sales × 12 × 4.9%. Stripe or PayPal processing fees come on top on every plan.

Over 3 yearsTotal
MemberPress Launch, with $1,000 a month in sales$2,761.50
MemberPress Scale$2,497.50
MemberPress Growth$1,747.50
Smart Creator Press 1-Site Elite$687

MemberPress: first year + two renewals (Launch adds $588 a year in fees). SCP: $229 × 3, which assumes the listed price holds.

To be fair to MemberPress, its own fix for the fee is Growth. Growth renews $300 a year higher than Launch, and 4.9% of about $510 a month in sales is the same $300. So if you sell more than about $510 a month, Growth costs less than Launch from year two on.

Bottom line

Over three years, MemberPress Growth comes to $1,747.50 and SCP 1-Site Elite to $687 at its listed price, a difference of $1,060.50.


Before you start

Do these while your MemberPress license is still active. I’d give it an evening, and not the week of a launch.

01

Take a full backup of your site

If anything looks wrong later, you can roll back.

02

Export your members

In MemberPress → Members, the export links are at the bottom of the page (MemberPress docs). This CSV is what you import into SCP.

03

Export your subscriptions

MemberPress → Subscriptions has the same export links. The Subscription column shows the ID your gateway gave each subscription (MemberPress docs).

04

List your active Stripe plans and PayPal products

You’ll map each one to an SCP membership, so write down which plan belongs to which membership.

05

Make sure you can log in to Stripe

You need Developers → Webhooks in your Stripe dashboard to add the SCP webhook.

Bottom line

Two CSVs, a list of plans and a backup. That’s your safety net before anything changes.


Step by step

This is the order I’d follow. Each step is tagged so you know who does the work.

1

Run the MemberPress migration tool Automatic

Your courses, modules, lessons and attached files come across into SCP.

2

Check a few lessons You do this

Open three or four lessons and fix any formatting that relied on custom styles.

3

Create your memberships and products You do this

Set the prices again in SCP. Use the same names your members already know.

4

Import your members Guided

Smart Creator → Members → Import, using your MemberPress CSV, and grant each person the right membership.

5

Add the Stripe webhook Guided

In Stripe, Developers → Webhooks, add https://yourdomain.com/?scp-webhook=stripe and turn on the events the guide lists.

6

Map your Stripe plans Guided

Smart Creator → Settings → Migration → Stripe Mapping. Connect each active plan to an SCP product or membership and save.

7

Map your PayPal products Guided

SCP settings → Migrations tab → PayPal Migration. Pick the PayPal product name and map it to an SCP membership.

8

Point your buy buttons at SCP checkout You do this

New buyers go through SCP from here on.

Automatic = SCP does it. You do this = on you. Guided = an SCP doc walks you through it. Sources: MemberPress migration, Stripe mapping, PayPal migration.

“A friend recommended Smart Creator Press, and within about 15 minutes of looking at it, I was sold. What amazes me most is how much it handles automatically.”

Cindy G · moved from AccessAlly


Keeping subscriptions billing

Your members’ subscriptions stay in Stripe and PayPal, so nobody has to cancel or buy again. SCP listens to the payments and gives access to the membership you mapped.

Stripe, member already imported

SCP updates their access and extends it to match the subscription cycle.

Stripe, member you missed

SCP creates their WordPress account automatically when the subscription comes through.

PayPal, member already added

Each successful recurring payment extends access to match the billing date.

PayPal, member not added yet

Access starts only after their next PayPal payment. The guide recommends adding existing recurring subscribers to SCP before or during the move so nobody gets locked out.

Stripe events the guide says to turn on
invoice.payment_succeeded
invoice.payment_failed
payment_intent.payment_failed
customer.subscription.updated
customer.subscription.deleted
charge.refunded (optional)

Source: Stripe Subscription Mapping, checked October 2, 2026.

Bottom line

Import your PayPal subscribers before you map PayPal. Stripe is more forgiving because SCP creates missing accounts, but importing everyone first keeps it clean.


After the move checklist

Give it a week of watching before you call it done.

01

Log in as a test member

Open a migrated course and a lesson inside it.

02

Click the attached downloads

PDFs and download links should open from the lesson.

03

Spot-check three imported members

Each should see the membership you granted in the import.

04

Watch the next Stripe renewal

After it bills, the member’s access in SCP should extend.

05

Watch the next PayPal renewal

Same check for a PayPal subscriber.

06

Buy your own product

Run a test order through SCP checkout and confirm access arrives.

07

Keep your MemberPress exports

Hold on to the member and subscription CSVs for your records.

Bottom line

The first renewal on each gateway is the real test. Once a Stripe and a PayPal renewal have each extended access in SCP, the move is done.


Stay or switch

Stay on MemberPress if…

  • Your renewal fits your budget and you use what your plan includes.
  • You’re mid-launch and can’t spare an evening plus a week of checks.
  • You want members and memberships moved by a tool, not just courses.
  • Your courses lean on heavy custom CSS you don’t want to redo.

Move to Smart Creator Press if…

  • Your renewal jumped and the listed $229 a year for 1 site fits better.
  • You’re on Launch and the 4.9% fee keeps adding up.
  • Your members pay through your own Stripe or PayPal account.
  • You want bumps, upsells, affiliates and email built into the same plugin.

Questions buyers ask

Does the migration tool move my MemberPress members?

No. It moves courses, modules, lessons and attached files. You import members from a MemberPress CSV under Smart Creator → Members → Import.

Will my active Stripe subscriptions keep billing?

Yes, once you add the SCP webhook in Stripe and map each plan under Smart Creator → Settings → Migration → Stripe Mapping. Members don’t buy again.

What happens to PayPal subscribers?

You map each PayPal product to an SCP membership. Subscribers you’ve already added get extended access on each payment; ones you haven’t added get access after their next payment.

How do I export my members from MemberPress?

Go to MemberPress → Members and use the export links at the bottom of the page. The Subscriptions page has the same links.

Will my course formatting survive?

The content does. If your courses used custom styles, the doc says some formatting tweaks might be needed.

How much cheaper is Smart Creator Press than MemberPress?

After year one, MemberPress is $399 to $999 a year and SCP 1-Site Elite is a listed $229, as of October 2, 2026. Over three years that’s $1,747.50 for MemberPress Growth against $687 for SCP, if its listed price holds.

My verdict

If your MemberPress renewal is coming up, run the two exports this week while your license is active. Then let the tool move your courses and work through the memberships, the import and the mapping in that order.

Pick the SCP plan that matches how many sites you run, and start with the course you sell most.

See Smart Creator Press plans

Disclaimer: Smart Creator Press is our own membership plugin. This page explains how to move from MemberPress to Smart Creator Press. We are not affiliated with MemberPress and we don’t sell or promote their product. MemberPress is a trademark of its owner. Prices and features come from MemberPress’s public website, checked October 2, 2026, and may have changed since.